Why a Healthy Baby Isn’t the Whole Story with Dr. Jessica Vernon

We live in a culture that really likes a plan. Set the goal, do the research, prepare, execute, check the boxes, get the result you want.

It makes sense we bring that same mindset into pregnancy and birth. We write birth plans, gather information, and imagine how we hope things will unfold. Birth is different, and so is postpartum. 

In this episode of Transformed by Birth, I sit down with OB/GYN, perinatal coach, and author Dr. Jessica Vernon to talk about what happens when our plans meet the unpredictability of birth and new parenthood. Jessica's own experience with severe postpartum anxiety, depression, and OCD changed the way she practices medicine, and her work now makes room for the emotional and psychological dimensions of this transition, not only the physical ones.

Why a Healthy Baby Isn’t the Whole Story with Dr. Jessica Vernon

A Birth Plan Isn't a Guarantee

Jessica offers an analogy in her book, Then Comes Baby, that lands for me. Birth can be a bit like a cross between a wedding and an emergency room. We can have a vision, we can make plans, and then there’s the weather, or in birth's case, the million variables we simply cannot predict.

We need to reconsider what we're actually preparing for. Jessica prefers talking about birth preferences, and even more, the values underneath them.

Why does this preference matter to you? What do you most want your care team to understand? A birth plan tells people what you hope will happen. 

Slow It Down to the Speed of the Laboring Brain

Many parents describe the moment birth pivots as sudden, even when there's technically time. True emergencies requiring an immediate decision are relatively rare. When there is time, we can ask for it!

This is where partners and doulas matter enormously. The person giving birth isn't always in a position to slow the room down. Someone who can say, "Hold on, we need a minute," creates space to stay part of the decision.

Dr. Jessica Vernon Quote

Birth Trauma Is Subjective, Not Objective

We can't determine whether a birth was traumatic just by looking at what happened. Jessica has cared for people through significant medical complications who came away feeling supported, and she's cared for people whose births looked straightforward on paper but felt traumatic to live through.

Knowing what's happening to your body matters. Feeling like the people around you are caring with you, not just doing things to you, matters. That's why "you're healthy and the baby's healthy" can land so painfully when someone is struggling with their birth experience. Gratitude for a healthy baby and genuine hurt can both be true at the same time.

We Need to Talk About Postpartum Mental Health Before Birth

After the birth of her first daughter, Jessica experienced severe anxiety, depression, and OCD for nearly two years. She was an OB/GYN, and she still wasn't prepared for what was happening to her. That experience reshaped the questions she now asks her patients.

Obstetric training spends enormous time on complications like preeclampsia and postpartum hemorrhage. Yet mental health conditions are also a leading cause of maternal illness and death, and families often reach postpartum without knowing what symptoms to watch for. 

We talked about postpartum psychosis specifically, the wider spectrum of perinatal mood and anxiety disorders, and why partners need to be part of these conversations before anyone is already struggling.

Dr. Jessica Vernon Quote

You Are Never Alone

When you're deep inside something difficult, whether that's a birth that didn't go as planned, postpartum anxiety, or the disorientation of early parenthood, it can feel deeply isolating. Know that you’re not alone! Others have been here, and there is community, even when reaching for it is hard.

If you’re struggling, Postpartum Support International is a click away.

Resources Mentioned in This Episode

  • Learn more about Jessica’s work, including her 1:1 perinatal coaching, on Dr. Jessica Vernon’s website and Instagram.
  • Learn more about Jessica’s book: Then Comes Baby: An Honest Conversation About Birth, Postpartum, and the Complex Transition to Parenthood 
  • Postpartum Support International (PSI): Support, education, provider resources, peer groups, and information for people experiencing perinatal mental health challenges: Postpartum Support International
  • PSI Perinatal/Postpartum Psychosis Resources: Information about signs, treatment, support groups, and resources for individuals and families affected by postpartum psychosis: Postpartum Psychosis Help
  • National Maternal Mental Health Hotline: Free, confidential support available 24/7 in the U.S. by call or text at 1-833-TLC-MAMA (1-833-852-6262): National Maternal Mental Health Hotline

Continue your exploration with more Transformed by Birth podcast episodes, and connect with us on Instagram @transformedbybirth where the conversation keeps unfolding.

 

About Dr. Britta Bushnell

is a writer, teacher, storyteller, and mentor who blends her eclectic training, years of experience, and areas of study into a unique offering for individuals, couples, professionals, and groups. Britta is currently deep at work writing her forthcoming book, Transformed by Birth: Illuminating cultural ideals to enhance the experience of childbirth.