Who Holds the Power in the Birth Room? with Nurse Mandy Irby

Ask most people who’s providing their care during birth, and they'll probably name their doctor or midwife. Yet the person who often spends the most time in the room is the nurse.

Nurses watch, listen, answer questions, read the room, communicate with the rest of the care team, and navigate the many layers of a hospital system while caring for someone through one of the most significant experiences of their life.

In this episode of Transformed by Birth, I sit down with nurse, educator, and founder of The Birth Nurse, Mandy Irby, to explore the complicated position nurses occupy in birth care and the tremendous opportunity they have to help change that care from within. 

Who Holds the Power in the Birth Room with Nurse Mandy Irby

Caught in the Middle

Nurses are taught that advocating for their patients is part of their role, yet they often have little influence over many of the larger decisions that shape how care is provided. They are navigating hospital policies, provider expectations, managers, staffing limitations, and a hierarchy that doesn't always reflect how much responsibility they carry at the bedside.

Mandy uses eating during labor as an example. A laboring person might simply be hungry and want a hamburger. The nurse, meanwhile, may be thinking about an order for clear liquids, what anesthesia will say, the possibility of nausea, or what could happen if a cesarean birth becomes necessary.

Ultimately, the nurse isn't there to "let" someone eat or prevent them from eating. 

Mandy describes her responsibility as providing information, sharing any concerns, and recognizing that the person giving birth gets to make the decision about their own body. 

Mandy Irby Quote

Nurses Bring Their Experiences Into the Room

Birth asks a great deal of the people providing care, too. A nurse may leave one room after something frightening or traumatic and walk directly into another person's labor.

There isn't always time or space to process what just happened.

As Mandy says, “we're carrying our whole human selves into this space with other whole humans, and it impacts us.”

Her work with embodied trauma-informed care helps nurses become more aware of what is happening in their own nervous systems. Fear from a previous experience can follow us. So can exhaustion, grief, stress, and the instinct to prevent something painful from happening again.

Recognizing those responses can help a nurse separate their own experience from what is happening for the person in front of them.

Respect Can Change the Story

Birth can leave us incredibly vulnerable. We may be unclothed, in pain, frightened, touched by people we barely know, and asked to make decisions while processing an enormous amount of information.

How we're treated in those moments can stay with us.

Mandy speaks about the opportunity nurses have to respect body boundaries, practice meaningful consent, and help someone experience what it feels like to be listened to and believed. For someone whose boundaries haven't always been respected, that experience can be especially significant. 

This is part of why Mandy sees nurses as having so much potential to change birth culture. They may not hold the most institutional power in the hospital, but their relationship with the person giving birth can be profoundly influential.

Mandy Irby Quote

Change Is Already Happening

Mandy has been working in birth care long enough to remember when conversations about autonomy, consent, trauma-informed care, and obstetric violence weren't happening nearly as openly as they are today.

She sees the difference in the nurses entering the profession now.

When Mandy recently asked a room of nursing students who the decision-maker is, someone immediately answered: the patient. These students are noticing practices and questioning systems much earlier than previous generations often did. 

There is still a great deal of work to do, but change doesn't only happen through sweeping hospital policies. It happens in the relationships unfolding inside those rooms every day.

At the end of our conversation, Mandy offers this reminder to parents: “I want parents to know that all parts of themselves are showing up for this transformation.”

Resources Mentioned in This Episode

  • Connect with Mandy Irby's via her website and Instagram, and learn about the Nurse Disruptor Series.

Continue your exploration with more Transformed by Birth podcast episodes, and connect with us on Instagram @transformedbybirth where the conversation keeps unfolding.

 

About Dr. Britta Bushnell

is a writer, teacher, storyteller, and mentor who blends her eclectic training, years of experience, and areas of study into a unique offering for individuals, couples, professionals, and groups. Britta is currently deep at work writing her forthcoming book, Transformed by Birth: Illuminating cultural ideals to enhance the experience of childbirth.